Tonal vs Tempo vs Mirror: Which is the best smart home gym equipment?

Medically reviewed by Ryan Ernsbarger, CPT, SNS

Our editors independently research, review, and recommend the best products. We may receive commissions on some (not all) purchases made from our chosen links. Learn more.

All these new fancy, new at home gyms are pretty next-level. They’re unique in their own ways: each seemingly designed for a different type of person. But they’re also sizable investments; there’s no arguing that. So before you think about buying a home gym this holiday season, you should be confident that you’re investing in one you vibe with, and that’s exactly what you’ll want to use for years to come.

But before we get too deep in the weeds comparing Tonal, Tempo, and Mirror: how do smart gyms, in general, stack up against traditional home gyms? You know: the rusty old dumbbells and bench in your garage, the treadmill that’s been unplugged for the last couple of years, and those P90X DVDs that are collecting dust in the cabinet? Do these devices actually deliver comparable results, and do they have the same staying power as a trusty ol’ set of iron? 

Or maybe you’re someone who spends all their time at a gym or on Classpass. Keep this in mind when you decide whether or not investing in a home gym is worthwhile for you:

Crazy, right? It adds up. If you’re interested in the newest wave of fitness tech, read on as we take a deep dive into three of the most innovative players in the space today: Tonal, Tempo, and the Mirror. None of them are cheap, which is exactly why we’re breaking each one down and pitting them against each other.

Table of Contents

What’s all the buzz around smart home gym equipment?

Smart home gym equipment offers consumers a few key benefits over the traditional way of doing things – whether it’s going to a public gym or buying gear for your garage. 

  1. The ability to invest money today into equipment you’ll be using for a long time. And if you’d rather not drop all the cash up front, each gym we’ll review offers the ability to finance your equipment into manageable payment plans. So with payments plans working out to costs similar to what you’d see at a traditional gym, they’re actually quite affordable in the long-term.
  2. Thousands of live and on-demand classes with legit fitness instructors that will not only keep you motivated, but also teach you how to use proper form while you exercise.
  3. The convenience, flexibility, and privacy that comes with not having to leave home. How many times have you skipped the gym simply because you didn’t feel like getting ready? (A lot, personally…)
  4. Performance tracking so you never stop improving and making those gains.
  5. Sleek designs that not only don’t look like ugly gym equipment, but in some cases look downright cool
While each of the Tonal, Tempo, and Mirror check all these boxes, they do have their own advantages, disadvantages, and corners of the fitness market. Let’s talk about ’em!

🤔 Tonal vs Tempo vs Mirror: Which one’s right for you?

Not all gym equipment accomplishes the same goal, and the same holds true for smart home equipment. We all have different body types, tendencies, interests, and goals when it comes to working out. So if you’re looking for that coveted, all-in-one piece of equipment that fills every possible need out there, I’m sorry to say it doesn’t exist (and honestly, probably won’t in our lifetimes). 

But what you will find is that each of these products fills certain needs, and does it really freaking well. 

First off, take a look at what each product has in common and in contrast. Start to think about the criteria you care about most in choosing the piece of equipment that’s right for you. And keep in mind that this is only the 30,000ft view, for now. 

Tonal vs Tempo vs Mirror: Smart Home Gym Equipment Feature Comparison

Starting price$2,495$2,995$1,845
Weights includedYes - dumbbells, barbell, weights, etc.Yes - cable machine, 200 lb
Live classes
Form check
Partner workouts
Rep counting
Strength training
Yoga and mobility✔ (+ form tracking)
Workout tracking
# of classesHundredsHundreds20,000+
1:1 Personal training$40 per class
Custom workouts

Each of these products share similarities and differences, but they all still look great on paper. While it’s always important to define each option by the boxes they check off, that doesn’t always paint the full picture. Let’s take a deeper dive into each one now: starting with the Tempo.